Reader Bennet Richt writes:
Lifelong Florida resident here with some advice to those evacuating as Hurricane Irma approaches. As background, I’m an NRA instructor and was teaching a basic pistol class a few years ago when someone asked me a question I didn’t have an answer to. That question was how do gun laws work when there’s a hurricane or a state of emergency?
I had just gotten my certification and I had no idea. Some research revealed some pretty interesting information that every gun owner exiting of the cone of (un)certainty should know about.
The state of Florida has very broad powers in the declaration of an emergency, and Governor Scott has already done so. Chapter 252 says what the state can and cannot do, but the local and state government can restrict your right to buy firearms if you don’t have any already.
FS 252.36 – Emergency Management Powers of the Governor
(5)(h): Suspend or limit the sale, dispensing, or transportation of alcoholic beverages, firearms, explosives, and combustibles. However, nothing contained in ss. 252.31-252.90 shall be construed to authorize the seizure, taking, or confiscation of firearms that are lawfully possessed, unless a person is engaged in the commission of a criminal act.
We joke about Koreans on rooftops and shooting looters, but regrettably, if you don’t have a gun now, there is a chance that you may not be able to legally buy one if things really go sideways and the state government clamps down.
I was at a convenience store after the last bad storm and the local sherriff’s office came in and roped off the entire beer cooler. A bunch of borderline alcoholics who buy their beer by the can were then barred from alcohol. I didn’t hang around long enough to see what the result of that looked like and I don’t advise anyone else to. The old Boy Scout adage of ‘be prepared’ was true when I was a kid and it’s just as true today.
Now, those of you who’ve read 252 may be thinking “no, they can’t prevent people from buying guns….” That’s not what the law says.
FS 870.044 – Automatic Emergency Measures
(1): 870.044 Whenever the public official declares that a state of emergency exists, pursuant to s. 870.043, the following acts shall be prohibited during the period of said emergency throughout the jurisdiction: (1) The sale of, or offer to sell, with or without consideration, any ammunition or gun or other firearm of any size or description. (2) The intentional display, after the emergency is declared, by or in any store or shop of any ammunition or gun or other firearm of any size or description. (3) The intentional possession in a public place of a firearm by any person, except a duly authorized law enforcement official or person in military service acting in the official performance of her or his duty.
While 870.43 specifies “an act of violence or a flagrant and substantial defiance of, or resistance to, a lawful exercise of public authority” rather than a storm, those are just the kinds of situations that can follow a big hurricane’s landfall. This goes back to the importance of being prepared.
A few other things to consider when evacuating:
Many hurricane shelters will be on city-owned or school district property where firearms are prohibited. Anyone remember the Gun Free School Zones Act? That’s still very much a thing. The only thing worse than losing your house is then ending up in the big house afterward. Many municipal grounds are no bueno for firearms carrying or possession.
Do you own a machinegun? AOW? SBR? SBS? Remember that ATF Form 5320.20 requires approval BEFORE any interstate movement. Silencers, however, are exempt. So if you’re heading north from Jacksonville Beach, your papers better be good to go before you pass that WELCOME TO GEORGIA sign. The ATF provides no legal exceptions for hurricane evacuations.
As difficult as it may be, my suggestion is to leave any NFA guns behind and, if possible, convert any SBR/SBS into a Title One configuration which makes it 5320.20 exempt before hightailing it for the state line.
One last thing. It hasn’t really come into play yet, but Governor Scott signed a bill into law in 2015 that exempts lawful gun owners from the concealed carry permit requirement during a mandatory evacuation order. Sounds like a great idea, right?
That’s definitely a benefit to Sunshine State gun owners, but if you cross a state line, you’re then subject to that state’s laws. Just because Georgia has reciprocity and recognizes Florida’s concealed weapons license, that does not mean they’ll extend that to unlicensed concealed carry during an evacuation order.
Nor is there a provision covering returning to your residence after the storm. So if you leave a mandatory evacuation area, you can legally conceal your handgun under the emergency declaration. But if you do the same while returning to your residence…that may not be covered. You’d hope for leeway in a post-disaster situation, but this is a classic case of a legislature that meant well, but didn’t think things through all the way.
Keeping those things in mind, Hurricane Irma — still a couple of days away — looks like the big one. Keep your ammo dry, have plenty of bottled water and canned goods, and get to know your neighbors during the inevitable power outages.
Bennett Richt is a lifelong Florida resident and NRA instructor who enjoys TTAG, puppies and long walks on the beach while carrying his SIG P320 concealed.
“Bennett Richt is a lifelong Florida resident and NRA instructor who enjoys TTAG, puppies and long walks on the beach while carrying his SIG P320 concealed.”
Just don’t drop that SIG. (Too soon?)
Ing,
Nah, it isn’t too soon. Besides, he doesn’t have to worry about his Sig P320 discharging if it falls out of his holster because it will land on soft sand. (He did say he likes walking on the beach with his concealed Sig P320.)
I don’t remember a test being done with a loaded magazine. Surely the center of gravity in a loaded gun and a “round in the chamber” gun is different.
Disclaimer: Own three P320’s.
Uh, am I understanding this correctly?
Therefore, you cannot have a concealed firearm in a public place (like a public road) even if you have a concealed carry license?
Interesting.
I do know in Florida, your car is considered an extension of your house.
IANAL, but I think for all practical purposes it depends where you are in Florida during that emergency.
Miami, Ft. Lauderdale, potential problem. Polk county (sound of banjos twanging) likely not a problem.
As of yesterday, Scott has declared an emergency.
Florida concealed carry permits are invalid for the duration except the first two days?
Fuck *that* noise….
Polk County? Sheriff Grady Judd is too busy macking for TV cameras and rounding up pedophiles to care about your CCW piece.
Most dangerous real estate in Florida is the area between Judd and a TV camera.
I don’t anticipate a problem where I am, but I am concerned for others in areas like Miami if it’s true carry permits are invalid except to evacuate…
are you willing to bet your life on Sheriff Judd not caring
What is Florida law about bearing a shotgun or rifle outside of hunting activity? Can you walk down a public street with a rifle slung over your back when there is no official state of emergency? When there is an official state of emergency?
No open carry except specific hunting/fishing activities.
Could you carry a rifle or shotgun fully enclosed in a scabbard on your back?
No, you cannot conceal long guns on your person. Only handguns.
You can have a loaded long gun in your vehicle without having to hide it though.
So ok to open carry if fishing from the now flooded streets, good to know…
I wonder if hunting for looters counts…
“I wonder if hunting for looters counts…”
You probably can’t bait for ’em…
Seems like in houston pretty much all the shelters wouldnt let people bring guns in. I guess youd have to have a relative or friend to go too in a safe area, leave the gun at home, or take your chances on your own.
The author makes a glaring mistake. You CANNOT convert an SBS or SBR into a Title I config. Once it’s in the registry, the receiver itself is the SBR/SBS. Simply swapping on a longer barrel doesn’t help you. The only way to unSBR is to send a letter asking to remove the item from the registry, which probably requires surrendering your tax-stamp.
My friend I am afraid that is it you who has made the mistake. You are allowed to travel across state lines with a SBR/SBS without an approved 5320.20 assuming the following. That the registered receiver does not have a barrel shorted than 16″ installed and that you do have the SBR upper in your possession.
Yep, configuration changes are allowed, and only the current state of the weapon matters as to whether it is an SBR or not.
Yet once a machine gun, always a machine gun.
The only thing that is true and consistent about the NFA is that it doesn’t make sense and it isn’t consistent.
Wrong. Fake news.
Or just not go anywhere and carry on like normal with a little more preparedness for the storm.
It is times like this where I’m glad I don’t live in FL anymore and don’t have to worry with their stupid gun laws.
Good info, though in my prior experience, people affected by this monster have a whole lot higher priorities and aren’t scouring the internet for the details of Florida state gun statutes. We were assured a few years ago this issue was corrected. Law Enforcement just doesn’t care. Provide a report of law-abiding evacuating citizens having their vehicles searched for firearms and I will happily retract my assertion. At least outside of Miami, anyway.
Some of the posters are confused
Concealed carry permits are still valid during an emergency
What is different during an emergency is that a concealed carry permit is not needed
Everyone who is not a prohibited person can concealed carry legally during the 48 hours of the emergency
Correct, though either way, this is the Republican-controlled Gunshine state. GTFO is all that folks and government employees in the path of this monster are worried about.
Comments are closed.