Did Roberts and Kavanaugh Give In To Senate Intimidation in NYSRPA Ruling?

The dissenting justices say that if there are any remaining issues, like the coffee break question, then the case isn’t moot. Alito’s opinion also references the political brouhaha surrounding this case, explaining: Five United States Senators, four of whom are members of the bar of this Court, filed a brief insisting that the case be dismissed. If the … Read more

Massachusetts Gun Court Claims 89% Conviction Rate

That is, ladies and gentlemen, an extremely high conviction rate. For comparison, here’s a round-up-ette of some Bay State courts’ conviction rates [via the Massachusetts Lawyer weekly]: “An analysis of the statewide Superior Court conviction rate in 2009 reveals that nearly two-thirds of the criminal defendants in Worcester County were acquitted of felony charges at trial. [For the math aversive, that’s just over a 25 percent conviction rate.] That stat is nearly 30 percentage points below the commonwealth’s overall trial conviction rate [make that around 50 percent, then] and 20 points lower than the county with the second worst results, Bristol County.” And you gotta think that the 50 percent-ish statewide stat includes some serious plea bargaining. Anyway, does that mean that the four-year-old Massachusetts Gun Court is kicking ass and taking names, or taking names and kicking ass? The Suffolk Couty DA in charge of such things is, surprise, claiming a major victory. [Note: 19 of 171 Gun Court cases ended in acquittal, yielding the headline stat. Read the DA’s four-year report here.] And, of course, Dan Conley’s linking the Court’s success to a reduction in violent crime. First, a little history from the man’s press release.

Read more